Faster and lower dose imaging: evaluating adaptive, constant gantry velocity and angular separation in fast low-dose 4D cone beam CT imaging.

BACKGROUND: The adoption of four-dimensional cone beam computed tomography (4DCBCT) for image-guided lung cancer radiotherapy is increasing, especially for hypofractionated treatments. However, the drawbacks of 4DCBCT include long scan times (∼240 s), inconsistent image quality, higher imaging dose than necessary, and streaking artifacts. With the emergence of linear accelerators that can acquire 4DCBCT scans in a short period of time (9.2 s) there is a need to examine the impact that these very fast gantry rotations have on 4DCBCT image quality. PURPOSE: This study investigates the impact of gantry velocity and angular separation between x-ray projections on image quality and its implication for fast low-dose 4DCBCT with emerging systems, such as the Varian Halcyon that provide fast gantry rotation and imaging. Large and uneven angular separation between x-ray projections is known to reduce 4DCBCT image quality through increased streaking artifacts. However, it is not known when angular separation starts degrading image quality. The study assesses the impact of constant and adaptive gantry velocity and determines the level when angular gaps impair image quality using state-of-the-art reconstruction methods. METHODS: This study considers fast low-dose 4DCBCT acquisitions (60-80 s, 200-projection scans). To assess the impact of adaptive gantry rotations, the angular position of x-ray projections from adaptive 4DCBCT acquisitions from a 30-patient clinical trial were analyzed (referred to as patient angular gaps). To assess the impact of angular gaps, variable and static angular gaps (20°, 30°, 40°) were introduced into evenly separated 200 projections (ideal angular separation). To simulate fast gantry rotations, which are on emerging linacs, constant gantry velocity acquisitions (9.2 s, 60 s, 120 s, 240 s) were simulated by sampling x-ray projections at constant intervals using the patient breathing traces from the ADAPT clinical trial (ACTRN12618001440213). The 4D Extended Cardiac-Torso (XCAT) digital phantom was used to simulate projections to remove patient-specific image quality variables. Image reconstruction was performed using Feldkamp-Davis-Kress (FDK), McKinnon-Bates (MKB), and Motion-Compensated-MKB (MCMKB) algorithms. Image quality was assessed using Structural Similarity-Index-Measure (SSIM), Contrast-to-Noise-Ratio (CNR), Signal-to-Noise-Ratio (SNR), Tissue-Interface-Width-Diaphragm (TIW-D), and Tissue-Interface-Width-Tumor (TIW-T). RESULTS: Patient angular gaps and variable angular gap reconstructions produced similar results to ideal angular separation reconstructions, while static angular gap reconstructions produced lower image quality metrics. For MCMKB-reconstructions, average patient angular gaps produced SSIM-0.98, CNR-13.6, SNR-34.8, TIW-D-1.5 mm, and TIW-T-2.0 mm, static angular gap 40° produced SSIM-0.92, CNR-6.8, SNR-6.7, TIW-D-5.7 mm, and TIW-T-5.9 mm and ideal produced SSIM-1.00, CNR-13.6, SNR-34.8, TIW-D-1.5 mm, and TIW-T-2.0 mm. All constant gantry velocity reconstructions produced lower image quality metrics than ideal angular separation reconstructions regardless of the acquisition time. Motion compensated reconstruction (MCMKB) produced the highest contrast images with low streaking artifacts. CONCLUSION: Very fast 4DCBCT scans can be acquired provided that the entire scan range is adaptively sampled, and motion-compensated reconstruction is performed. Importantly, the angular separation between x-ray projections within each individual respiratory bin had minimal effect on the image quality of fast low-dose 4DCBCT imaging. The results will assist the development of future 4DCBCT acquisition protocols that can now be achieved in very short time frames with emerging linear accelerators.

X-ray source arrays for volumetric imaging during radiotherapy treatment.

This work presents a novel hardware configuration for radiotherapy systems to enable fast 3D X-ray imaging before and during treatment delivery. Standard external beam radiotherapy linear accelerators (linacs) have a single X-ray source and detector located at ± 90° from the treatment beam respectively. The entire system can be rotated around the patient acquiring multiple 2D X-ray images to create a 3D cone-beam Computed Tomography (CBCT) image before treatment delivery to ensure the tumour and surrounding organs align with the treatment plan. Scanning with a single source is slow relative to patient respiration or breath holds and cannot be performed during treatment delivery, limiting treatment delivery accuracy in the presence of patient motion and excluding some patients from concentrated treatment plans that would be otherwise expected to have improved outcomes. This simulation study investigated whether recent advances in carbon nanotube (CNT) field emission source arrays, high frame rate (60 Hz) flat panel detectors and compressed sensing reconstruction algorithms could circumvent imaging limitations of current linacs. We investigated a novel hardware configuration incorporating source arrays and high frame rate detectors into an otherwise standard linac. We investigated four potential pre-treatment scan protocols that could be achieved in a 17 s breath hold or 2-10 1 s breath holds. Finally, we demonstrated for the first time volumetric X-ray imaging during treatment delivery by using source arrays, high frame rate detectors and compressed sensing. Image quality was assessed quantitatively over the CBCT geometric field of view as well as across each axis through the tumour centroid. Our results demonstrate that source array imaging enables larger volumes to be imaged with acquisitions as short as 1 s albeit with reduced image quality arising from lower photon flux and shorter imaging arcs.

Thoracic motion-compensated cone-beam computed tomography in under 20 seconds on a fast-rotating linac: A simulation study.

BACKGROUND: Rapid kV cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) scans are achievable in under 20 s on select linear accelerator systems to generate volumetric images in three dimensions (3D). Daily pre-treatment four-dimensional CBCT (4DCBCT) is recommended in image-guided lung radiotherapy to mitigate the detrimental effects of respiratory motion on treatment quality. PURPOSE: To demonstrate the potential for thoracic 4DCBCT reconstruction using projection data that was simulated using a clinical rapid 3DCBCT acquisition protocol. METHODS: We simulated conventional (1320 projections over 4 min) and rapid (491 projections over 16.6 s) CBCT acquisitions using 4D computed tomography (CT) volumes of 14 lung cancer patients. Conventional acquisition data were reconstructed using the 4D Feldkamp-Davis-Kress (FDK) algorithm. Rapid acquisition data were reconstructed using 3DFDK, 4DFDK, and Motion-Compensated FDK (MCFDK). Image quality was evaluated using Contrast-to-Noise Ratio (CNR), Tissue Interface Width (TIW), Root-Mean-Square Error (RMSE), and Structural SIMilarity (SSIM). RESULTS: The conventional acquisition 4DFDK reconstructions had median phase averaged CNR, TIW, RMSE, and SSIM of 2.96, 8.02 mm, 83.5, and 0.54, respectively. The rapid acquisition 3DFDK reconstructions had median CNR, TIW, RMSE, and SSIM of 2.99, 13.6 mm, 112, and 0.44 respectively. The rapid acquisition MCFDK reconstructions had median phase averaged CNR, TIW, RMSE, and SSIM of 2.98, 10.2 mm, 103, and 0.46, respectively. Rapid acquisition 4DFDK reconstruction quality was insufficient for any practical use due to sparse angular projection sampling. CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest that 4D motion-compensated reconstruction of rapid acquisition thoracic CBCT data are feasible with image quality approaching conventional acquisition CBCT data reconstructed using standard 4DFDK.

Extended Intraoperative Longitudinal 3-Dimensional Cone Beam Computed Tomography Imaging With a Continuous Multi-Turn Reverse Helical Scan.

OBJECTIVES: Cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) imaging is becoming an indispensable intraoperative tool; however, the current field of view prevents visualization of long anatomical sites, limiting clinical utility. Here, we demonstrate the longitudinal extension of the intraoperative CBCT field of view using a multi-turn reverse helical scan and assess potential clinical utility in interventional procedures. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A fixed-room robotic CBCT imaging system, with additional real-time control, was used to implement a multi-turn reverse helical scan. The scan consists of C-arm rotation, through a series of clockwise and anticlockwise rotations, combined with simultaneous programmed table translation. The motion properties and geometric accuracy of the multi-turn reverse helical imaging trajectory were examined using a simple geometric phantom. To assess potential clinical utility, a pedicle screw posterior fixation procedure in the thoracic spine from T1 to T12 was performed on an ovine cadaver. The multi-turn reverse helical scan was used to provide postoperative assessment of the screw insertion via cortical breach grading and mean screw angle error measurements (axial and sagittal) from 2 observers. For all screw angle measurements, the intraclass correlation coefficient was calculated to determine observer reliability. RESULTS: The multi-turn reverse helical scans took 100 seconds to complete and increased the longitudinal coverage by 370% from 17 cm to 80 cm. Geometric accuracy was examined by comparing the measured to actual dimensions (0.2 ± 0.1 mm) and angles (0.2 ± 0.1 degrees) of a simple geometric phantom, indicating that the multi-turn reverse helical scan provided submillimeter and degree accuracy with no distortion. During the pedicle screw procedure in an ovine cadaver, the multi-turn reverse helical scan identified 4 cortical breaches, confirmed via the postoperative CT scan. Directly comparing the screw insertion angles (n = 22) measured in the postoperative multi-turn reverse helical and CT scans revealed an average difference of 3.3 ± 2.6 degrees in axial angle and 1.9 ± 1.5 degrees in the sagittal angle from 2 expert observers. The intraclass correlation coefficient was above 0.900 for all measurements (axial and sagittal) across all scan types (conventional CT, multi-turn reverse helical, and conventional CBCT), indicating excellent reliability between observers. CONCLUSIONS: Extended longitudinal field-of-view intraoperative 3-dimensional imaging with a multi-turn reverse helical scan is feasible on a clinical robotic CBCT imaging system, enabling long anatomical sites to be visualized in a single image, including in the presence of metal hardware.

Reducing 4DCBCT imaging dose and time: exploring the limits of adaptive acquisition and motion compensated reconstruction.

This study investigates the dose and time limits of adaptive 4DCBCT acquisitions (adaptive-acquisition) compared with current conventional 4DCBCT acquisition (conventional-acquisition). We investigate adaptive-acquisitions as low as 60 projections (∼25 s scan, 6 projections per respiratory phase) in conjunction with emerging image reconstruction methods. 4DCBCT images from 20 patients recruited into the adaptive CT acquisition for personalized thoracic imaging clinical study (NCT04070586) were resampled to simulate faster and lower imaging dose acquisitions. All acquisitions were reconstructed using Feldkamp-Davis-Kress (FDK), McKinnon-Bates (MKB), motion compensated FDK (MCFDK), motion compensated MKB (MCMKB) and simultaneous motion estimation and image reconstruction (SMEIR) algorithms. All reconstructions were compared against conventional-acquisition 4DFDK-reconstruction using Structural SIMilarity Index (SSIM), signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), contrast-to-noise-ratio (CNR), tissue interface sharpness diaphragm (TIS-D), tissue interface sharpness tumor (TIS-T) and center of mass trajectory (COMT) for difference in diaphragm and tumor motion. All reconstruction methods using 110-projection adaptive-acquisition (11 projections per respiratory phase) had a SSIM of greater than 0.92 relative to conventional-acquisition 4DFDK-reconstruction. Relative to conventional-acquisition 4DFDK-reconstruction, 110-projection adaptive-acquisition MCFDK-reconstructions images had 60% higher SNR, 10% higher CNR, 30% higher TIS-T and 45% higher TIS-D on average. The 110-projection adaptive-acquisition SMEIR-reconstruction images had 123% higher SNR, 90% higher CNR, 96% higher TIS-T and 60% higher TIS-D on average. The difference in diaphragm and tumor motion compared to conventional-acquisition 4DFDK-reconstruction was within submillimeter accuracy for all acquisition reconstruction methods. Adaptive-acquisitions resulted in faster scans with lower imaging dose and equivalent or improved image quality compared to conventional-acquisition. Adaptive-acquisition with motion compensated-reconstruction enabled scans with as low as 110 projections to deliver acceptable image quality. This translates into 92% lower imaging dose and 80% less scan time than conventional-acquisition.

The first-in-human implementation of adaptive 4D cone beam CT for lung cancer radiotherapy: 4DCBCT in less time with less dose.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: We present the first implementation of Adaptive 4D cone beam CT (4DCBCT) that adapts the image hardware (gantry rotation speed and kV projections) in response to the patient's real-time respiratory signal. Adaptive 4DCBCT was applied on lung cancer patients to reduce the scan time and imaging dose in the ADaptive CT Acquisition for Personalised Thoracic imaging (ADAPT) trial. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The ADAPT technology measures the patient's real-time respiratory signal and uses mathematical optimisation and external circuitry attached to the linear accelerator to modulate the gantry rotation speed and kV projection rate to reduce scan times and imaging dose. For each patient, ADAPT scans were acquired on two treatment fractions and reconstructed with a motion compensated reconstruction algorithm and compared to the current state-of-the-art four-minute 4DCBCT acquisition (conventional 4DCBCT). We report on the scan time, imaging dose and image quality for the first four adaptive 4DCBCT patients. RESULTS: The ADAPT imaging dose was reduced by 85% and scan times were 73 ± 12 s representing a 70% reduction compared to the 240 s conventional 4DCBCT scan. The contrast-to-noise ratio was improved from 9.2 ± 3.9 with conventional 4DCBCT to 11.7 ± 4.1 with ADAPT. DISCUSSION: The ADAPT trial represents the first time that gantry rotation speed and projection acquisition have been adapted and optimised in real-time in response to changes in the patient's breathing. ADAPT demonstrates substantially reduced scan times and imaging dose for clinical 4DCBCT imaging that could enable more efficient and optimised lung cancer radiotherapy.

Reducing 4DCBCT scan time and dose through motion compensated acquisition and reconstruction.

Conventional 4DCBCT captures 1320 projections across 4 min. Adaptive 4DCBCT has been developed to reduce imaging dose and scan time. This study investigated reconstruction algorithms that best complement adaptive 4DCBCT acquisition for reducing imaging dose and scan time whilst maintaining or improving image quality compared to conventional 4DCBCT acquisition using real patient data from the first 10 adaptive 4DCBCT patients. Adaptive 4DCBCT was implemented in the ADaptive CT Acquisition for Personalized Thoracic imaging clinical trial. Adaptive 4DCBCT modulates gantry rotation speed and kV acquisition rate in response to the patient's real-time respiratory signal, ensuring even angular spacing between projections at each respiratory phase. We examined the first 10 lung cancer radiotherapy patients that received adaptive 4DCBCT. Fast, 200-projection scans over 60-80 s, and slower, 600-projection scans over ∼240 s, were obtained after routine patient treatment and compared against conventional 4DCBCT acquisition. Adaptive 4DCBCT acquisitions were reconstructed using Feldkamp-Davis-Kress (FDK), McKinnon-Bates (MKB), Motion Compensated FDK (MCFDK) and Motion Compensated MKB (MCMKB) algorithms. Reconstructions were assessed via, Structural SIMilarity (SSIM), Signal-to-Noise-Ratio (SNR), Contrast-to-Noise-Ratio (CNR), Tissue Interface Sharpness of Diaphragm (TIS-D) and Tumor (TIS-T). The 200- and 600-projection adaptive 4DCBCT acquisition corresponded to 85% and 55% reduction in imaging dose, shorter and similar scan times of approximately 90 s and 236 s respectively, compared to conventional 4DCBCT acquisition. 200- and 600-projection adaptive 4DCBCT reconstructions achieved more than 0.900 SSIM relative to conventional 4DCBCT acquisition. Compared to conventional 4DCBCT acquisition, 200-projection adaptive 4DCBCT reconstructions achieved higher SNR, CNR, TIS-T, TIS-D with motion compensated algorithms, MCFDK (208%, 159%, 174%, 247%) and MCMKB (214%, 173%, 266%, 245%) respectively. The 200-projection adaptive 4DCBCT MCFDK- and MCMKB-reconstruction results show image quality improvements are possible even with 85% fewer projections acquired. We established acquisition-reconstruction protocols that provide substantial reductions in imaging time and dose whilst improving image quality.

Adaptive CaRdiac cOne BEAm computed Tomography (ACROBEAT): Developing the next generation of cardiac cone beam CT imaging.

PURPOSE: An important factor when considering the use of interventional cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) imaging during cardiac procedures is the trade-off between imaging dose and image quality. Accordingly, Adaptive CaRdiac cOne BEAm computed Tomography (ACROBEAT) presents an alternative acquisition method, adapting the gantry velocity and projection rate of CBCT imaging systems in accordance with a patient's electrocardiogram (ECG) signal in real-time. The aim of this study was to experimentally investigate that ACROBEAT acquisitions deliver improved image quality compared to conventional cardiac CBCT imaging protocols with fewer projections acquired. METHODS: The Siemens ARTIS pheno (Siemens Healthcare, GmbH, Germany), a robotic CBCT C-arm system, was used to compare ACROBEAT with a commercially available conventional cardiac imaging protocol that utilizes multisweep retrospective ECG-gated acquisition. For ACROBEAT, real-time control of the gantry position was enabled through the Siemens Test Automation Control system. ACROBEAT and conventional image acquisitions of the CIRS Dynamic Cardiac Phantom were performed, using five patient-measured ECG traces. The traces had average heart rates of 56, 64, 76, 86, and 100 bpm. The total number of acquired projections was compared between the ACROBEAT and conventional acquisition methods. The image quality was assessed via the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), structural similarity index (SSIM), and root-mean square error (RMSE). RESULTS: Compared to the conventional protocol, ACROBEAT reduced the total number of projections acquired by 90%. The visual image quality provided by the ACROBEAT acquisitions, across all traces, matched or improved compared to conventional acquisition and was independent of the patient's heart rate. Across all traces, ACROBEAT averaged 1.4 times increase in the CNR, a 23% increase in the SSIM and a 29% decrease in the RMSE compared to conventional and was independent of the patient's heart rate. CONCLUSION: Adaptive patient imaging is feasible on a clinical robotic CBCT system, delivering higher quality images while reducing the number of projections acquired by 90% compared to conventional cardiac imaging protocols.

Toward improved 3D carotid artery imaging with Adaptive CaRdiac cOne BEAm computed Tomography (ACROBEAT).

PURPOSE: Interventional treatments of aneurysms in the carotid artery are increasingly being supplemented with three-dimensional (3D) x-ray imaging. The 3D imaging provides additional information on device sizing and stent malapposition during the procedure. Standard 3D x-ray image acquisition is a one-size fits all model, exposing patients to additional radiation and results in images that may have cardiac-induced motion blur around the artery. Here, we investigate the potential of a novel dynamic imaging technique Adaptive CaRdiac cOne BEAm computed Tomography (ACROBEAT) to personalize image acquisition by adapting the gantry velocity and projection rate in real-time to changes in the patient's electrocardiogram (ECG) trace. METHODS: We compared the total number of projections acquired, estimated carotid artery widths and image quality between ACROBEAT and conventional (single rotation fixed gantry velocity and acquisition rate, no ECG-gating) scans in a simulation study and a proof-of-concept physical phantom experimental study. The simulation study dataset consisted of an XCAT digital software phantom programmed with five patient-measured ECG traces and artery motion curves. The ECG traces had average heart rates of 56, 64, 76, 86, and 100 bpm. To validate the concept experimentally, we designed and manufactured the physical phantom from an 8-mm diameter silicon rubber tubing cast into Phytagel. An artery motion curve and the ECG trace with an average heart rate of 56 bpm was passed through the phantom. To implement ACROBEAT on the Siemens ARTIS pheno angiography system for the proof-of-concept experimental study, the Siemens Test Automation Control System was used. The total number of projections acquired and estimated carotid artery widths were compared between the ACROBEAT and conventional scans. As the ground truth was available for the simulation studies, the image quality metrics of Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) and Structural Similarity Index (SSIM) were also utilized to assess image quality. RESULTS: In the simulation study, on average, ACROBEAT reduced the number of projections acquired by 63%, reduced carotid width estimation error by 65%, reduced RMSE by 11% and improved SSIM by 27% compared to conventional scans. In the proof-of-concept experimental study, ACROBEAT enabled a 60% reduction in the number of projections acquired and reduced carotid width estimation error by 69% compared to a conventional scan. CONCLUSION: A simulation and proof-of-concept experimental study was completed applying a novel dynamic imaging protocol, ACROBEAT, to imaging the carotid artery. The ACROBEAT results showed significantly improved image quality with fewer projections, offering potential applications to intracranial interventional procedures negatively affected by cardiac motion.

Evaluating reconstruction algorithms for respiratory motion guided acquisition.

Conventional thoracic 4DCBCT scans take 1320 projections over 4 min. This paper investigates which reconstruction algorithms best leverage Respiratory-Motion-Guided (RMG) acquisition in order to reduce scan time and dose while maintaining image quality. We investigated a 200 projection, on average 1 min RMG acquisition. RMG acquisition ensures even angular separation between projections at each respiratory phase by adjusting the imaging gantry rotation to the patient respiratory signal in real time. Conventional 1320 projection data and RMG 200 projection data were simulated from 4DCT volumes of 14 patients. Each patient had an initial 4DCT reconstruction, treated as a planning 4DCT, and a 4DCT reconstruction acquired later, used for 4DCBCT data simulation and evaluation. Reconstructions were computed using the Feldkamp-David-Kress (FDK), McKinnon-Bates (MKB), RecOnstructiOn using Spatial and TEmporal Regularization (ROOSTER), and Motion Compensated FDK (MCFDK) algorithms. We also introduced and evaluated a novel MCMKB algorithm. Image quality was evaluated with Root-Mean-Square Error (RMSE), Structural SIMilarity index (SSIM) and Tissue Interface Sharpness (TIS). Rigid registration of the tumor volume regions between the reconstruction and the ground truth was used to evaluate geometric accuracy. Relative to conventional 4DCBCT acquisition, the RMG acquisition delivered 80% less dose and was on average 70% faster. The conventional-acquisition 4DFDK-reconstruction volumes had mean RMSE, SSIM, TIS and geometric error of 94, 0.9987, 2.69 and 1.19 mm respectively. The RMG-acquisition MCFDK-reconstruction volumes had mean RMSE, SSIM, TIS and geometric error of 113, 0.9986, 1.76 and 1.77 mm respectively with minimal increase in computational cost. These results suggest scan time and dose can be significantly reduced with minimal impact on reconstruction quality by implementing RMG acquisition and motion compensated reconstruction.

Dual cardiac and respiratory gated thoracic imaging via adaptive gantry velocity and projection rate modulation on a linear accelerator: A Proof-of-Concept Simulation Study.

PURPOSE: Cardiac motion is typically not accounted for during pretreatment imaging for central lung and mediastinal tumors. However, cardiac induced tumor motion averages 5.8 mm for esophageal tumors and 3-5 mm for some lung tumors, which can result in positioning errors. Our aim is to reduce both cardiac- and respiratory-induced motion artifacts in thoracic cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) images through gantry velocity and projection rate modulation on a standard linear accelerator (linac). METHODS: The acquisition of dual cardiac and respiratory gated CBCT thoracic images was simulated using the XCAT phantom with patient-measured respiratory and ECG traces. The gantry velocity and projection rate were modulated based on the cardiac and respiratory signals to maximize the angular consistency between adjacent projections in the gated cardiac-respiratory bin. The mechanical limitations of a gantry-mounted CBCT system were investigated. For our protocol, images were acquired during the 60%-80% window of cardiac phase and 20% displacement either side of peak exhale of the respiratory cycle. The comparator method was the respiratory-only gated CBCT acquisition with constant gantry speed and projection rate in routine use for respiratory correlated four-dimensional (4D) CBCT. All images were reconstructed using the Feldkamp-Davis-Kress (FDK) algorithm. The methods were compared in terms of image sharpness as measured using the edge response width (ERW) and contrast as measured using the contrast to noise ratio (CNR). The effects of the total number of projections acquired and magnitude of cardiac motion on scan time and image quality were also investigated. RESULTS: Median total scan times with our protocol ranged from 117 s (40 projections) through to 296 s (100 projections), compared with 240 s for the conventional protocol (1320 projections). The scan times were dictated by the number of projections acquired, heart rate, length of the respiratory cycle and mechanical constraints of the CBCT system. Our protocol was able to provide between 8% and 43% decrease in the median value of the ERW in the anterior/posterior (AP) direction across the 17 traces when there was 0.5 cm of cardiac motion and between 35% and 64% decrease when there was 1.0 cm of cardiac motion over conventional acquisition. In the superior-inferior (SI) direction, our protocol was able to provide between 22% and 26% decrease in the median value of the ERW across the 17 traces when there was 0.5 cm of cardiac motion and between 30% and 35% decrease when there was 1.0 cm of cardiac motion over conventional acquisition. The magnitude of the cardiac motion did not have an observable effect on the median value of the CNR. Across all 17 traces, our adaptive protocol produced noticeably more consistent, albeit lower CNR values compared with conventional acquisition. CONCLUSION: For the first time, the potential of adapting CBCT image acquisition to changes in the patient's cardiac and respiratory rates simultaneously for applications in radiotherapy was investigated. This work represents a step towards thoracic imaging that reduces the effects of both cardiac and respiratory motion on image quality.

Towards patient connected imaging with ACROBEAT: Adaptive CaRdiac cOne BEAm computed Tomography.

Robotic C-arm cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) systems are playing an increasingly pivotal role in interventional cardiac procedures and high precision radiotherapy treatments. One of the main challenges in any form of cardiac imaging is mitigating the intrinsic motion of the heart, which causes blurring and artefacts in the 3D reconstructed image. Most conventional 3D cardiac CBCT acquisition techniques attempt to combat heart motion through retrospective gating techniques, whereby acquired projections are sorted into the desired cardiac phase after the completion of the scan. However, this results in streaking artefacts and unnecessary radiation exposure to the patient. Here, we present our Adaptive CaRdiac cOne BEAm computed Tomography (ACROBEAT) acquisition protocol that uses the patient's electrocardiogram (ECG) signal to adaptively regulate the gantry velocity and projection time interval in real-time. It enables prospectively gated patient connected imaging in a single sweep of the gantry. The XCAT digital software phantom was used to complete a simulation study to compare ACROBEAT to a conventional multi-sweep retrospective ECG gated acquisition, under a variety of different acquisition conditions. The effect of location and length of the acquisition window and total number of projections acquired on image quality and total scan time were examined. Overall, ACROBEAT enables up to a 5 times average improvement in the contrast-to-noise ratio, a 40% reduction in edge response width and an 80% reduction in total projections acquired compared to conventional multi-sweep retrospective ECG gated acquisition.

Real-time respiratory triggered four dimensional cone-beam CT halves imaging dose compared to conventional 4D CBCT.

Four dimensional cone-beam computed tomography (4D CBCT) improves patient positioning and the accuracy of radiation therapy for patients with mobile tumours. Generally, 4D CBCT requires many hundreds of x-ray projections to measure target trajectories and the imaging frequency is not adapted to the patient's respiratory signal resulting in over-sampling. In contrast, respiratory triggered 4D CBCT (RT 4D CBCT) is an acquisition technique that has been experimentally implemented and has shown to reduce the number of x-ray projections and thus 4D CBCT dose with minimal impact on image quality. The aim of this work is to experimentally investigate RT 4D CBCT in situ and measure target trajectory mean position, image quality and imaging dose from this approach. A commercially available phantom with programmable target motion was programmed with nine target trajectories derived from patient-measured respiratory traces known to span the range of image quality when used for 4D CBCT reconstruction. 4D CBCT datasets were acquired for each target trajectory using the RT 4D CBCT acquisition technique and the conventional 4D CBCT acquisition technique. From the reconstructed 4D CBCT datasets, target trajectory mean positions, imaging dose and image quality metrics were calculated and compared between the two techniques. Target trajectory and mean position were measured by tracking the target's displacement in the phantom; imaging dose was measured by counting the total number of x-ray projections acquired; and image quality was assessed by calculating the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), signal-to-noise ration (SNR) and edge response width (ERW). For each of the nine cases, the target trajectory mean position as determined by RT 4D CBCT and conventional 4D CBCT varied from the reference source trajectory mean position by 0.7 mm or less except for one case where a conventional 4D CBCT mean position varied by 1.3 mm. On the average of these nine studies, RT 4D CBCT required half as many projections as conventional 4D CBCT giving a 50% reduction in imaging dose. Overall, the image quality metrics (CNR and SNR) were marginally worse for RT 4D CBCT; ERW metric showed no statistically significant difference between the RT 4D CBCT and conventional 4D CBCT reconstructed datasets. Respiratory triggered 4D CBCT couples the real-time respiratory signal to the 4D CBCT image acquisition system and requires less imaging dose than conventional 4D CBCT to determine target trajectory mean positions.

Audiovisual biofeedback guided breath-hold improves lung tumor position reproducibility and volume consistency.

PURPOSE: Respiratory variation can increase the variability of tumor position and volume, accounting for larger treatment margins and longer treatment times. Audiovisual biofeedback as a breath-hold technique could be used to improve the reproducibility of lung tumor positions at inhalation and exhalation for the radiation therapy of mobile lung tumors. This study aimed to assess the impact of audiovisual biofeedback breath-hold (AVBH) on interfraction lung tumor position reproducibility and volume consistency for respiratory-gated lung cancer radiation therapy. METHODS: Lung tumor position and volume were investigated in 9 patients with lung cancer who underwent a breath-hold training session with AVBH before 2 magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) sessions. During the first MRI session (before treatment), inhalation and exhalation breath-hold 3-dimensional MRI scans with conventional breath-hold (CBH) using audio instructions alone and AVBH were acquired. The second MRI session (midtreatment) was repeated within 6 weeks after the first session. Gross tumor volumes (GTVs) were contoured on each dataset. CBH and AVBH were compared in terms of tumor position reproducibility as assessed by GTV centroid position and position range (defined as the distance of GTV centroid position between inhalation and exhalation) and tumor volume consistency as assessed by GTV between inhalation and exhalation. RESULTS: Compared with CBH, AVBH improved the reproducibility of interfraction GTV centroid position by 46% (P = .009) from 8.8 mm to 4.8 mm and GTV position range by 69% (P = .052) from 7.4 mm to 2.3 mm. Compared with CBH, AVBH also improved the consistency of intrafraction GTVs by 70% (P = .023) from 7.8 cm3 to 2.5 cm3. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated that audiovisual biofeedback can be used to improve the reproducibility and consistency of breath-hold lung tumor position and volume, respectively. These results may provide a pathway to achieve more accurate lung cancer radiation treatment in addition to improving various medical imaging and treatments by using breath-hold procedures.

Reducing 4DCBCT imaging time and dose: the first implementation of variable gantry speed 4DCBCT on a linear accelerator.

Four dimensional cone beam computed tomography (4DCBCT) uses a constant gantry speed and imaging frequency that are independent of the patient's breathing rate. Using a technique called respiratory motion guided 4DCBCT (RMG-4DCBCT), we have previously demonstrated that by varying the gantry speed and imaging frequency, in response to changes in the patient's real-time respiratory signal, the imaging dose can be reduced by 50-70%. RMG-4DCBCT optimally computes a patient specific gantry trajectory to eliminate streaking artefacts and projection clustering that is inherent in 4DCBCT imaging. The gantry trajectory is continuously updated as projection data is acquired and the patient's breathing changes. The aim of this study was to realise RMG-4DCBCT for the first time on a linear accelerator. To change the gantry speed in real-time a potentiometer under microcontroller control was used to adjust the current supplied to an Elekta Synergy's gantry motor. A real-time feedback loop was developed on the microcontroller to modulate the gantry speed and projection acquisition in response to the real-time respiratory signal so that either 40, RMG-4DCBCT40, or 60, RMG-4DCBCT60, uniformly spaced projections were acquired in 10 phase bins. Images of the CIRS dynamic Thorax phantom were acquired with sinusoidal breathing periods ranging from 2 s to 8 s together with two breathing traces from lung cancer patients. Image quality was assessed using the contrast to noise ratio (CNR) and edge response width (ERW). For the average patient, with a 3.8 s breathing period, the imaging time and image dose were reduced by 37% and 70% respectively. Across all respiratory rates, RMG-4DCBCT40 had a CNR in the range of 6.5 to 7.5, and RMG-4DCBCT60 had a CNR between 8.7 and 9.7, indicating that RMG-4DCBCT allows consistent and controllable CNR. In comparison, the CNR for conventional 4DCBCT drops from 20.4 to 6.2 as the breathing rate increases from 2 s to 8 s. With RMG-4DCBCT, the ERW in the direction of motion of the imaging insert decreases from 2.1 mm to 1.1 mm as the breathing rate increases from 2 s to 8 s while for conventional 4DCBCT the ERW increases from 1.9 mm to 2.5 mm. Image quality can be controlled during 4DCBCT acquisition by varying the gantry speed and the projection acquisition in response to the patient's real-time respiratory signal. However, although the image sharpness, i.e. ERW, is improved with RMG-4DCBCT, the ERW depends on the patient's breathing rate and breathing regularity.

The first implementation of respiratory triggered 4DCBCT on a linear accelerator.

Four dimensional cone beam computed tomography (4DCBCT) is an image guidance strategy used for patient positioning in radiotherapy. In conventional implementations of 4DCBCT, a constant gantry speed and a constant projection pulse rate are used. Unfortunately, this leads to higher imaging doses than are necessary because a large number of redundant projections are acquired. In theoretical studies, we have previously demonstrated that by suppressing redundant projections the imaging dose can be reduced by 40-50% for a majority of patients with little reduction in image quality. The aim of this study was to experimentally realise the projection suppression technique, which we have called Respiratory Triggered 4DCBCT (RT-4DCBCT). A real-time control system was developed that takes the respiratory signal as input and computes whether to acquire, or suppress, the next projection trigger during 4DCBCT acquisition. The CIRS dynamic thorax phantom was programmed with a 2 cm peak-to-peak motion and periods ranging from 2 to 8 s. Image quality was assessed by computing the edge response width of a 3 cm imaging insert placed in the phantom as well as the signal to noise ratio of the phantoms tissue and the contrast to noise ratio between the phantoms lung and tissue. The standard deviation in the superior-inferior direction of the 3 cm imaging insert was used to assess intra-phase bin displacement variations with a higher standard deviation implying more motion blur. The 4DCBCT imaging dose was reduced by 8.6%, 41%, 54%, 70% and 77% for patients with 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8 s breathing periods respectively when compared to conventional 4DCBCT. The standard deviation of the intra-phase bin displacement variation of the 3 cm imaging insert was reduced by between 13% and 43% indicating a more consistent position for the projections within respiratory phases. For the 4 s breathing period, the edge response width was reduced by 39% (0.8 mm) with only a 6-7% decrease in the signal to noise and contrast to noise ratios. RT-4DCBCT has been experimentally realised and reduced to practice on a linear accelerator with a measurable imaging dose reductions over conventional 4DCBCT and little degradation in image quality.

Real-Time 3D Image Guidance Using a Standard LINAC: Measured Motion, Accuracy, and Precision of the First Prospective Clinical Trial of Kilovoltage Intrafraction Monitoring-Guided Gating for Prostate Cancer Radiation Therapy.

PURPOSE: Kilovoltage intrafraction monitoring (KIM) is a new real-time 3-dimensional image guidance method. Unlike previous real-time image guidance methods, KIM uses a standard linear accelerator without any additional equipment needed. The first prospective clinical trial of KIM is underway for prostate cancer radiation therapy. In this paper we report on the measured motion accuracy and precision using real-time KIM-guided gating. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Imaging and motion information from the first 200 fractions from 6 patient prostate cancer radiation therapy volumetric modulated arc therapy treatments were analyzed. A 3-mm/5-second action threshold was used to trigger a gating event where the beam is paused and the couch position adjusted to realign the prostate to the treatment isocenter. To quantify the in vivo accuracy and precision, KIM was compared with simultaneously acquired kV/MV triangulation for 187 fractions. RESULTS: KIM was successfully used in 197 of 200 fractions. Gating events occurred in 29 fractions (14.5%). In these 29 fractions, the percentage of beam-on time, the prostate displacement was >3 mm from the isocenter position, reduced from 73% without KIM to 24% with KIM-guided gating. Displacements >5 mm were reduced from 16% without KIM to 0% with KIM. The KIM accuracy was measured at <0.3 mm in all 3 dimensions. The KIM precision was <0.6 mm in all 3 dimensions. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical implementation of real-time KIM image guidance combined with gating for prostate cancer eliminates large prostate displacements during treatment delivery. Both in vivo KIM accuracy and precision are well below 1 mm.

Audiovisual Biofeedback Improves Cine-Magnetic Resonance Imaging Measured Lung Tumor Motion Consistency.

PURPOSE: To assess the impact of an audiovisual (AV) biofeedback on intra- and interfraction tumor motion for lung cancer patients. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Lung tumor motion was investigated in 9 lung cancer patients who underwent a breathing training session with AV biofeedback before 2 3T magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) sessions. The breathing training session was performed to allow patients to become familiar with AV biofeedback, which uses a guiding wave customized for each patient according to a reference breathing pattern. In the first MRI session (pretreatment), 2-dimensional cine-MR images with (1) free breathing (FB) and (2) AV biofeedback were obtained, and the second MRI session was repeated within 3-6 weeks (mid-treatment). Lung tumors were directly measured from cine-MR images using an auto-segmentation technique; the centroid and outlier motions of the lung tumors were measured from the segmented tumors. Free breathing and AV biofeedback were compared using several metrics: intra- and interfraction tumor motion consistency in displacement and period, and the outlier motion ratio. RESULTS: Compared with FB, AV biofeedback improved intrafraction tumor motion consistency by 34% in displacement (P=.019) and by 73% in period (P<.001). Compared with FB, AV biofeedback improved interfraction tumor motion consistency by 42% in displacement (P<.046) and by 74% in period (P=.005). Compared with FB, AV biofeedback reduced the outlier motion ratio by 21% (P<.001). CONCLUSIONS: These results demonstrated that AV biofeedback significantly improved intra- and interfraction lung tumor motion consistency for lung cancer patients. These results demonstrate that AV biofeedback can facilitate consistent tumor motion, which is advantageous toward achieving more accurate medical imaging and radiation therapy procedures.

Quantifying the image quality and dose reduction of respiratory triggered 4D cone-beam computed tomography with patient-measured breathing.

Respiratory triggered four dimensional cone-beam computed tomography (RT 4D CBCT) is a novel technique that uses a patient's respiratory signal to drive the image acquisition with the goal of imaging dose reduction without degrading image quality. This work investigates image quality and dose using patient-measured respiratory signals for RT 4D CBCT simulations. Studies were performed that simulate a 4D CBCT image acquisition using both the novel RT 4D CBCT technique and a conventional 4D CBCT technique. A set containing 111 free breathing lung cancer patient respiratory signal files was used to create 111 pairs of RT 4D CBCT and conventional 4D CBCT image sets from realistic simulations of a 4D CBCT system using a Rando phantom and the digital phantom, XCAT. Each of these image sets were compared to a ground truth dataset from which a mean absolute pixel difference (MAPD) metric was calculated to quantify the degradation of image quality. The number of projections used in each simulation was counted and was assumed as a surrogate for imaging dose. Based on 111 breathing traces, when comparing RT 4D CBCT with conventional 4D CBCT, the average image quality was reduced by 7.6% (Rando study) and 11.1% (XCAT study). However, the average imaging dose reduction was 53% based on needing fewer projections (617 on average) than conventional 4D CBCT (1320 projections). The simulation studies have demonstrated that the RT 4D CBCT method can potentially offer a 53% saving in imaging dose on average compared to conventional 4D CBCT in simulation studies using a wide range of patient-measured breathing traces with a minimal impact on image quality.

Multileaf Collimator Tracking Improves Dose Delivery for Prostate Cancer Radiation Therapy: Results of the First Clinical Trial.

PURPOSE: To test the hypothesis that multileaf collimator (MLC) tracking improves the consistency between the planned and delivered dose compared with the dose without MLC tracking, in the setting of a prostate cancer volumetric modulated arc therapy trial. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Multileaf collimator tracking was implemented for 15 patients in a prostate cancer radiation therapy trial; in total, 513 treatment fractions were delivered. During each treatment fraction, the prostate trajectory and treatment MLC positions were collected. These data were used as input for dose reconstruction (multiple isocenter shift method) to calculate the treated dose (with MLC tracking) and the dose that would have been delivered had MLC tracking not been applied (without MLC tracking). The percentage difference from planned for target and normal tissue dose-volume points were calculated. The hypothesis was tested for each dose-volume value via analysis of variance using the F test. RESULTS: Of the 513 fractions delivered, 475 (93%) were suitable for analysis. The mean difference and standard deviation between the planned and treated MLC tracking doses and the planned and without-MLC tracking doses for all 475 fractions were, respectively, PTV D99% -0.8% ± 1.1% versus -2.1% ± 2.7%; CTV D99% -0.6% ± 0.8% versus -0.6% ± 1.1%; rectum V65% 1.6% ± 7.9% versus -1.2% ± 18%; and bladder V65% 0.5% ± 4.4% versus -0.0% ± 9.2% (P<.001 for all dose-volume results). CONCLUSION: This study shows that MLC tracking improves the consistency between the planned and delivered doses compared with the modeled doses without MLC tracking. The implications of this finding are potentially improved patient outcomes, as well as more reliable dose-volume data for radiobiological parameter determination.